Best Pizza in Mauldin

Enjoy Delicious, Freshly Made Pizzas & More!
Order From Our Website

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.
Order Now

Only Fresh Ingredients

Only Fresh Ingredients
Tato's Pizzeria and Restaurant is all about quality. We use only the freshest ingredients, sourced from trusted sources, to ensure that you receive the best possible product. Our commitment to quality is evident in every step of our preparation process, ensuring that each dish we serve meets our high standards. When you order from us, you can rest assured knowing that you're getting something special - a meal made with love and care, using only the finest ingredients. Indulge in flavor today!

Come for the Pizza, Stay for the Experience

Come for the Pizza, Stay for the Experience
At Tato's Pizzeria and Restaurant, we pride ourselves on being a team that puts our passion and dedication into all aspects of the business. Our enthusiasm helps us to make your experience with us top-notch. We are lucky to have such an amazing group of professionals who show up every day, ready to go above and beyond for our customers. Our secret ingredient is caring deeply not only about what their customer needs, but also the team members they interact with. From start to finish, everyone here is devoted to delivering the most incredible experience possible — and we’re so excited for you to be part of it! Stop by any time and see for yourself what secret ingredient makes us stand out from the competition!

Featuring

Gluten-Free Options

Healthy Options

Easy Parking

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

Tato’s is such a hidden gem that we are so thankful to have found. Their Colombian food is delicious & authentic, and the pizza is perfect (from the crust to the toppings). Our daughter will only eat pizza from here now, she loves Colombian & BBQ pizza. Thank you to the owner & staff for always being consistent with the quality of your food & having excellent service!

Leah J.

Leah J.

Pizza was so DELICIOUS!! I'm a cheese pizza lover and Tato's is the best. The pizza was thin and soft dough. It was the first time for me and my husband. We met Tato, the owner, he is very nice and of good service. He recommended we try "Colombian Empanadas" and we love them. We will definitely be back to try a new one next time. Thanks for making the awesome food 😊

Tanya L.

Tanya L.

Wonderful discovery! Friendly, local place with international flair! Great pizza - handmade and tossed with secret recipe crust. Courteous service, extensive menu, and good prices. Colombian offerings and flavors are a plus!

Rhoades B.

Rhoades B.

Went tonight with my family and everything was delicious. My kids loved the pizza and the jalapeño poppers are the best I have had in a minute. The staff is very nice and welcoming. We enjoyed our dinner very much and can’t wait to come back. Thank you 😋

Marie O.

Marie O.

Stopped here for a change in restaurants and this place has the best cheeseburger I've ever had. The staff was super friendly and the prices are pretty low for the amount of food they give you. I can't wait to try the other menu items in the future.

Thomas H.

Thomas H.

If you are looking for some fantastic pizza this is the place to go, I can’t tell you how many times I’ve driven by here and I finally called and ordered a veggie pizza, I’m sad it took me this long to try them out. Friendly staff upon arrival, Colombian owners and we had a great chat, clean, and lots of soda options if you like soda. This will definitely be my go-to pizza place from now on, you are welcome!

Grace M.

Grace M.

John Sebastian (Chef / Owner)

John Sebastian (Chef / Owner)
Chef John Sebastian has been cooking up a storm at his simple place for years. Offering a variety of international foods, Chef John Sebastian has something for everyone- and he makes it all look easy! He’s been featured in various food magazines and cooking shows, and his restaurant has become a local favorite in the community. When he’s not in the kitchen, Chef John Sebastian enjoys spending time with his family.

About Us

About Us
Since we opened our doors, Tato's pizza has been a simple place with a variety of international foods. We have something for everyone, with a focus on tasty pasta dishes, appetizers, hamburgers and wings. Plus, we offer the best salads in town! If you’re looking for something different – whether it’s foreign food or a delicious sandwich – Tato's is the place to be. Come see us today!
Tato's Pizzeria and Restaurant Rewards

Tato's Pizzeria and Restaurant Rewards

Join our rewards program to earn points, get free items, and stay up to date with us.

Frequently asked questions

Our location